Could Jensen Ackles Be the Next Great Live-Action Batman?

He’s played a demon hunter, a soldier-turned-superhero, and even a cowboy, but lately, Jensen Ackles has been making waves as the voice of a certain Caped Crusader. That’s right, folks, the “Supernatural” heartthrob has lent his vocal talents to not one, but seven DC animated films, bringing a new level of grit and gravitas to the iconic Batman.

But with such a diverse range of storylines and a revolving door of directors, not all Batman outings are created equal. So, grab your batarangs and let’s dive into the animated world of Jensen Ackles’ Batman, ranking his performances from “meh” to “holy Bat-voice, that’s amazing!”

7. “Legion of Super-Heroes” (2023): A Super-Snub for Batman?
Let’s face it, this movie belonged to Supergirl, leaving Batman relegated to the sidelines. While Ackles’ performance is solid (who doesn’t love a brooding Batman?), he doesn’t get much room to shine, making this a forgettable entry in his Bat-resume.

#6. “Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths – Part Two” (2024): Lost in the Multiverse
Multiverse mayhem often makes for epic storytelling, but it can also lead to overcrowded narratives. Such is the case with “Crisis on Infinite Earths – Part Two.

Ackles’ Batman, while present, struggles to stand out amidst a sea of superheroes and villains.
#5. “Justice League: Warworld” (2023): A Showcase of Range, Buried Under a Messy Plot
This one had potential. Ackles gets to play Batman across various genres, from sword-wielding warrior to hard-boiled detective, showcasing his impressive range.

Unfortunately, the overall film is a jumbled mess, leaving Ackles’ stellar voice work lost in the shuffle.

#4. “Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths – Part Three” (2024): A Bittersweet Farewell
The final chapter of the “Crisis on Infinite Earths” trilogy gives Ackles a few moments to shine, particularly in his interactions with Constantine and his poignant struggle to accept the end of the multiverse.

However, the film is ultimately overshadowed by the legendary Kevin Conroy’s final performance as Batman, making this a bittersweet entry for Ackles.

#3. “Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths – Part One” (2024): Emotional Depth and Dad Jokes? Yes, Please!

The first installment of “Crisis on Infinite Earths” offers a glimpse into Ackles’ ability to bring emotional depth to the Batman. His interactions with the Earth-2 Batfamily, particularly his alternate-universe daughter, are both heartwarming and heartbreaking, revealing a softer side to the often-stoic hero.

2. “Batman: The Long Halloween – Part One” (2021): A Masterclass in Brooding Intensity
The first half of the “Long Halloween” adaptation allows Ackles to truly sink his teeth into the role. We see Batman grapple with a complex mystery, navigate his relationships with Gordon, Catwoman, and Harvey Dent, and confront his own inner demons.

It’s a tour de force of brooding intensity.
#1. “Batman: The Long Halloween – Part Two” (2021): A Triumphant Turn as a Broken Bat
Ackles delivers his most powerful performance as Batman in the emotionally charged conclusion of “The Long Halloween.” From Bruce Wayne’s vulnerable reflections on his childhood to Batman’s chilling confrontation with the Holiday killer, Ackles captures the nuances of a hero grappling with grief, rage, and a thirst for justice.

From Animation to Live-Action? Fans Hope to See Ackles Don the Cape
With seven animated films under his belt, Jensen Ackles has proven he has the vocal chops and the emotional range to bring Batman to life. Now, the question on everyone’s mind is: will we ever see him don the cape and cowl in a live-action film?

Only time will tell, but with DC Studios shaking things up, anything is possible. And one thing’s for sure, if Ackles does get the call, fans will be first in line to see him take on the mantle of the Bat.